摘要
从司法实务看,当前帮助信息网络犯罪活动罪的适用逻辑并未完全遵循刑法教义学的逻辑,考虑到实际效果,其允许一定的自由裁量。这虽然在提升打击数量和提高办案效率上起到促进作用,却可能造成政府、司法机关、企业、公民之间关系出现一些结构性问题。比如,企业、公民的刑事法律风险没有得到合理控制,政府的治理作用没有更进一步明确。为此,笔者认为当前刑事司法政策有必要完善,在入罪上给予一定的条件限制,在出罪上给予一定的政策空间。
In judicial practice,the current application logic of the crime of assisting information network criminal activities does not fully follow the logic of criminal jurisprudence.Taking the practical effect into account,the application logic of this crime allows for judicial discretion to some extent,which might have played a positive role in enhancing combat against the crime and the efficiency of handling cases,nevertheless,it may also cause some structural problems in the relationship between the government,judicial organs,enterprises and citizens.For example,the risk of criminal responsibility for enterprises and citizens has not been properly controlled,and the regulative role of the government has not been further clarified.For this reason,it is necessary to improve the current criminal justice policy,setting certain conditions and restrictions on incrimination,and giving certain policy leeway on exoneration.
出处
《数字法治》
2023年第2期181-193,共13页
DIGITAL LAW
基金
贵州省人民检察院2022年检察理论研究课题“帮助信息网络犯罪活动罪罪名适用实务问题研究”研究成果。
作者简介
范思力,贵州省人民检察院一级检察官助理,全国检察调研骨干人才,法学硕士。
