摘要
我国司法实践没有清晰划定经济犯罪的处罚边界,需要在优化营商环境政策的指导下,对民营企业家经济犯罪的刑事解释给予体系性思考。一方面,应当对机能主义刑法解释论进行外在体系制约,明确优化营商环境政策的价值基础和有关非刑法规范的价值属性。另一方面,应当对机能主义刑法解释论进行内在体系制约,明确民营企业家经济犯罪客观危害和主观罪过的判断基准。总之,只有逻辑性思考和目的性思考并重,才能构建本土化的机能主义刑法体系的价值基准,并将其用于经济犯罪的刑法解释。
The boundary of punishment of economic crimes has not clearly defined in China’s judicial practice,so the interpretation of criminal law of economic crimes of private entrepreneurs should be considered systematically under the guidance of optimizing business environment policy.On the one hand,the interpreter needs to give the functional interpretation of criminal law with external system restriction in order to clarify the value basis of optimizing business environment policy and the value attribute of non-criminal norms.On the other hand,the interpreter has to endow the functional interpretation of criminal law with internal system restriction for clearing the judgment standards of objective harm and subjective fault of economic crimes of private entrepreneurs.In a word,only by paying equal attention to logical thinking and purposeful thinking,we can construct the value standards of localized system of functional criminal law and apply it to the interpretation of criminal law of economic crimes.
出处
《刑法论丛》
2022年第2期34-77,共44页
Criminal Law Review
基金
2020年国家社科基金后期资助项目“机能主义刑法学的本土化研究”(项目批准号:20FFXB046)之阶段性成果
关键词
优化营商环境政策
民营企业家经济犯罪
机能主义刑法解释论
逻辑性
目的性
Optimizing Business Environment Policy
Economic Crimes of Private Entrepreneurs
Functional Interpretation of Criminal Law
Logicality
Purpose
作者简介
李冠煜,华中科技大学法学院副教授,法学博士,博士生导师。
