摘要
刑事庭前会议程序的有效运行对于促成庭审实质化具有重要意义,它可以解决与刑事庭审有关的程序性事项,促进庭审的集中、连贯进行,避免审判程序在形式和实质上的不必要中断,从而提高庭审效率、保证庭审质量。检审与分析样本地区庭前会议实施情况发现,庭前会议与理论及制度预设仍存有差距。庭前会议启动方式职权化特点突出,会议报告形成过程缺乏监督,非法证据排除程序尚有瑕疵。因此,增加控辩双方申请启动庭前会议的救济性权利,增设会议报告形成过程的监督程序,建立非法证据排除的告知制度,是未来庭前会议程序完善的必要内容。
The effective operation of the pre-trial proceedings of the criminal courts is important to promote the substantive nature of the trial,to solve the procedural matters related to the criminal trial,to promote the centralized and coherent conduct of the trial,and to avoid unnecessary interruption of the trial procedure in form and essence,thereby improving the efficiency of the trial and guaranteeing the quality of the trial.However,based on the review and analysis of the implementation of the pre-trial meeting in the sample area,it is found that there is still a realistic gap between the operational effects and the theoretical and institutional presuppositions.The pre-trial meeting initiation mode has prominent functions,and the meeting report formation lacks supervision and illegality.There is still a flaw in the evidence exclusion process.According to the text research,although the legislation clearly defines the rights of the accused and the effectiveness of the pre-trial meeting and the rules of evidence are also significantly improved,there are still some unsatisfactory things.Therefore,it is necessary to increase the remedial rights of the application for the initiation of the meeting between the prosecution and the defense,establish the supervision mechanism for the report of the meeting and set up the notification mode for the exclusion of illegal evidence.
作者
毛淑玲
王鹤
Mao Shuling;Wang He(School of Law,Liaoning Normal University,Dalian 116081,China)
出处
《辽宁师范大学学报（社会科学版）》
2019年第6期75-80,共6页
Journal of Liaoning Normal University(Social Science Edition)
基金
辽宁省教育厅服务地方项目“辽南地区刑事庭审实质化实践研究——以大连地区法院为检视样本”(WF201783618)
关键词
刑事
庭前会议
启动
监督
非法证据排除
criminal case
pre-trial meeting
start
supervision
exclusion of illegal evidence
作者简介
毛淑玲(1970-),女,山西忻州人,辽宁师范大学副教授,主要从事诉讼法学、法律逻辑学、证据法学研究.
