摘要
南通切除智障少女子宫案中,被告被诉故意伤害罪。然而,本案中存在明显的法律漏洞,被告不能因国家法律的漏洞而承担刑事责任。根据民事主体法律规范的立法意图,应通过相关的司法审查程序赋予监护人对被监护人的有限人身处分权,监护人从被监护人利益出发切除被监护人子宫的行为应排除在故意伤害罪的定罪范围之外。
In the case about a girl of unhealthy mind whose womb was ablated in Nantong, the defendants were sued with crime of intentional violence. Yet, there are obviously legal flaws in the case and there is no reason for letting the defendants to bear criminal liability for the legal flaws. According to the legislation intention of civil legal principle, relevant judicial procedure is needed to endure mentor with limited right of personal decision, at the same time,the act of ablating the womb of that girl of unhealthy mind for the benefits of herself should be brushed aside from the dimension of the crime of intentional violence.
出处
《武汉理工大学学报（社会科学版）》
2006年第4期544-548,共5页
Journal of Wuhan University of Technology:Social Sciences Edition
关键词
智障少女
子宫切除
法律漏洞
法律思考
a girl of unhealthy mind
womb being ablated
legal flaw
legal thought
作者简介
罗欢平（1978-），女，湖南省浏阳市人，武汉大学民商法博士生，南京审计学院讲师，主要从事民商法、经济法研究。
