摘要
监察从宽处罚建议作为监察处置阶段适用认罪认罚从宽的前置程序,其可实现实体权利上的从宽与程序上的从简效果。囿于监察从宽处罚建议适用规范相对概括,立法应避免将其过度具体化以防止僭越刑罚裁量权的司法功能。从法解释学视角考量,监察机关作出从宽处罚建议应然须担负提前告知义务与全面收集证据义务。在配套衔接刑事诉讼程序时,应注重把握监察权内涵、案件调查、规范适用与程序审查等方面限度。从立法完善层面,须注重概括型从宽处罚建议实体从宽与程序从简的底线基准,此可为有效衔接精准量刑建议提供合理参考。
The suggestion of leniency in supervision,as the pre-procedure of leniency in confession and punishment,can achieve the effect of leniency in substantive rights and simplification in procedure.Constrained by the relatively generalization of the applicable norms of the suggestion of lenient punishment,legislation should avoid its over-concretization,so as to prevent the judicial function of criminal law discretion from being overstepped.From the perspective of legislative hermeneutics,the supervisory organ should shoulder the obligation of informing in advance and collecting evidence comprehensively when making lenient punishment suggestions.We should pay attention to grasping the limits of the connotation of supervision power,case investigation,application of norms and procedure review.From the aspect of legislative perfection,we should pay attention to the bottom line benchmark of generalized leniency and simplified procedure,which can provide a reasonable reference for effectively linking accurate sentencing recommendations.
作者
王译
李嘉飞
WANG YI;LI JIAFEI(School of Law Xiangtan University,Xiangtan Hunan 411105,China;Xiangtan university Anti-corruption judicial research base,Xiangtan Hunan 411105,China)
基金
湖南省教育厅科学研究一般项目(项目编号:20C1781)
国家“2011计划”司法文明协同创新中心资助项目(教技函2013[26])
关键词
从宽处罚建议
精准量刑
客观公正
应然限度
Suggestions on lenient punishment
Accurate sentencing
Objective and fair
Due limit
作者简介
王译(1988-),男,湖南邵阳人,湘潭大学法学院,法学博士,研究方向:监察法学,刑事诉讼法学;李嘉飞(1999-),男,山西吕梁人,湘潭大学反腐败司法研究基地,研究方向:监察法学。
