主题新颖性程度—融合程度—影响力三维视角下的学术论文创新性评价研究被引量：1

Study on the Evaluation of Academic Papers'Innovativeness from the Three-Dimensional Perspective of the Degree of Novelty-Integration-Influence of the Topic

在线阅读下载PDF

导出

摘要 [目的/意义]如何科学、合理地评价学术论文创新水平和科学价值成为研究的关注点。本研究构建了融合主题新颖性程度、融合程度、影响力三维的学术论文创新性评价方式,将为学术论文创新性评价相关研究提供借鉴。[方法/过程]本研究基于学术论文研究主题内容及价值,从学术论文研究主题新颖性程度、主题融合程度和主题影响力3个维度,采用TOPSIS法,构建主题新颖性程度—融合程度—影响力三维视角下的学术论文创新性评价模型,并以2021年度人文社会科学中区块链为研究主题的学术论文为研究对象,进行实证研究。[结果/结论]研究发现,当前我国人文社会科学区块链研究维持着较高的增长态势,且其关注度在稳定的同时略有变化;所构建的主题新颖性程度—融合程度—影响力三维视角下的学术论文创新性评价模型可作为研究活动和绩效的衡量标准,丰富了学术论文创新性评价方式。 [Purpose/Significance]How to scientifically and rationally evaluate the innovation level and scientific value of academic papers has become a research concern.This study constructs a three-dimensional evaluation method of academic papers'innovativeness integrating the degree of novelty,integration and influence of the topic,which would provide reference for the research related to the evaluation of academic papers'innovativeness.[Method/Process]Based on the content and value of academic paper research themes,this study used the TOPSIS method to construct a three-dimensional evaluation model of academic papers'innovativeness integrating the degree of novelty,integration and influence of the topic.This research conducted empirical research on academic papers with the theme of blockchain in the humanities and social sciences in 2021 in China.[Result/Conclusion]The study finds that:the current blockchain research in the humanities and social sciences maintains a high growth trend,and its attention is stable while slightly changing in China;the construction of the three-dimensional evaluation model of academic papers'innovativeness integrating the degree of novelty,integration and influence of the topic can be used as a measure of research activities and performance,enriches the way of evaluating the innovativeness of academic papers,can be used as a measure of research activities and performance,enriches the innovative evaluation methods of academic papers.

作者魏绪秋常霞姜召昊申力旭 Wei Xuqiu;Chang Xia;Jiang Zhaohao;Shen Lixu(School of Information Management,Shandong University of Technology,Zibo 255000,China)

机构地区山东理工大学信息管理学院

出处《现代情报》 CSSCI 北大核心 2024年第3期131-139,177,共10页 Journal of Modern Information

基金国家社会科学基金青年项目“基于文本挖掘的学术论文创新性识别研究”(项目编号:21CTQ022)。

关键词学术论文创新性评价主题新颖性程度主题融合程度主题影响力 TOPSIS法区块链 academic paper innovativeness evaluation degree of topic novelty degree of topic integration degree of topic value TOPSIS method block chain

分类号 G250.252 [文化科学—图书馆学]

作者简介魏绪秋(1990-),男,副教授,博士,硕士生导师,研究方向:信息计量、科学评价与数据挖掘;常霞(1999-),女,硕士研究生,研究方向:信息计量、科学评价与数据挖掘研究;姜召昊(1999-),男,硕士研究生,研究方向:信息计量、科学评价与数据挖掘研究;申力旭(1998-),女,硕士研究生,研究方向:信息计量、科学评价与数据挖掘研究。