国际商事仲裁一裁终局的困境与出路被引量：7

Dilemma and Solution of Final Ruling of International Commercial Primary Arbitrament

在线阅读下载PDF

导出

摘要传统观点认为,一裁终局是仲裁相对于诉讼的主要优点之一。但随着国际商事交往规模的日益扩大,一裁终局在国际商事仲裁领域内除了效率性结果外,还带来了公正性缺失的可能性,并且现行的司法审查制度也不能从根本上消除这一问题。因此,应当将商事仲裁视为主要是契约因素与裁决权威性因素的结合,增设当事人协议进行的"二次仲裁",同时,尽可能回退司法因素,以利于仲裁的发展。 A traditional view holds that one of the advantages of arbitrament as opposed to lawsuit is final ruling of primary arbitrament. However, along with the increasingly enlarged scale of international commercial activities, this advantage entails, besides its efficiency, possibility of fairness deficiency, which the existent judicial review system cannot eliminate fundamental- ly. Therefore, it is a must to regard commercial arbitrament principally as a combination between contractual factors and arbitrating authority factors, to set up ＂secondary arbitrament＂ of involved parties bargaining, and for the arbitrament to turn to judicial factors with the chief goal of facilitating its development.

作者孟昭华

机构地区四川师范大学法学院

出处《四川师范大学学报（社会科学版）》 CSSCI 北大核心 2007年第4期15-20,共6页 Journal of Sichuan Normal University(Social Sciences Edition)

关键词国际商事仲裁一裁终局二次仲裁契约因素司法因素裁决权威性因素 international commercial arbitrament final ruling of primary arbitrament secondary arbitrament judicial factors arbitrating authority factors

分类号 D997.4 [政治法律—国际法学]

作者简介孟昭华（1980-），女，黑龙江佳木斯人，教师，西南政法大学国际法硕士研究生。

引文网络
相关文献

参考文献10

1Neil Kaplan.Arbitration in Asia:Developments and Crises[J].Amsterdam:Journal of International Arbitration,19(2),2002.
2William H.Knull.Ⅲ and Noah D.Rubins.Betting the Farm on International Arbitrations:Is it Time to Offer an Appeal Option?[J].The American Review of International Arbitration,2000,(11).
3[英]艾伦·雷德芬,马丁·亨特,等.国际商事仲裁法律与实践(第四版)[M].林一飞,宋连斌译.北京:北京大学出版社,2005.
4赵秀文.从克罗马罗依案看国际仲裁裁决的撤销与执行[J].法商研究（中南财经政法大学学报）,2002,19(5):116-128. 被引量：21
5申琳.从《纽约公约》“更优权利条款”谈国际商事仲裁裁决撤销的对世效力[J].濮阳职业技术学院学报,2004,17(4):26-27. 被引量：2
6陈正伟,李芳.古埃及的仲裁[J].仲裁与法律,2004(1):119-127. 被引量：2
7Petmr Bowman Rutledge.On the Importance of Institutions:Review of Arbitral Awards for Legal Errors[J].Amsterdam:Journal of International Arbitration,2002.
8CPR Institute for Dispute Resolution,CPR Arbitration Appeal Procedure (December 22,1999)[EB/OL].Http://www.cpadr.org/.
9张宇燕.过河的中美故事[N].南方周末,2005-11-24(D26).
10Cecilia M.Di Cio.Dealing with Mistakes Contained in Arbitral Awards[J].The American Review of International Arbitration,2001,(12).

二级参考文献29

1Yearbook Commercial Arbitration, 1999, pp. 265-266
2Journal of International Arbitration, June 1997, No. 2, pp. 125-126
3Journal of International Arbitration,September 1997 ,No. 3, pp. 142-145.
4See Gary H. Sampliner, Enforcement of Nullified Froeign Arbitral Awards, Journal of International Arbitration,September 1997,No. 3,p. 145 ,p. 142.
5Yearbook Commercial Arbitration, 1999, pp. 265-268.
6Ahmed S. El - Kosheri, The Enforcement of Awards Nullified in the Country of Origin.伯格主编.《国际商事仲裁会议文件选编》,克鲁沃国际出版公司1999年英文版，第545页.
7Yearbook of Commercial Arbitration, Vol.22, 1997, pp. 1001-1012,pp. 691-695.
8Tibor Varady, John J. Barcelo, and Arthur T. Von Mehren, International Commercial Arbitration,West Group, 1999, pp.788-795.
9Jan Paulsson, Rediscovering the N.Y. Convention: Further Reflections on Chromalloy, 12 Mealey's Int'l Arb. Rep.(April 1997) 20, p. 30
10Georges R. Delaume, Enforcement Against a Foreign State of Arbitral Award Annulled in the Foreign State, Revue de Droit des Affaires Internationales (1997), No. 2, p. 253.