期刊文献+

论测谎结论的证据适用 被引量:15

On Evidence Application of Lie-detecting Conclusion
在线阅读 下载PDF
导出
摘要 测谎结论已经进入到我国司法领域,但对于测谎结论的属性还存在种种争议。测谎具有鉴定结论的所有特征,应当属于鉴定结论,并拥有鉴定结论的证据效力。但是由于测谎技术鉴定对象的特殊性,在适用测谎结论时不能等同于普通的物证鉴定,必须设定一些限制性规则,在发挥科技手段提高司法效率的同时兼顾保障被测人的合法权利。 The conclusion of lie-detection has entered the procedures of judicature in our country, but there is still controversy towards the nature of the lie-detecting conclusion. Lie detection has all the features of defining the conclusion. It belongs to the defining conclusion and owns the proof effect of defining conclusion. But, owing to the particularity of the defined subject by lie-detecting technology, it is not equal to the normal material definition when using the lie-detecting conclusion. It should be done to set up some restraint principles to ensure the legal right of the detected when increasing the judicatory efficiency in using the scientific means.
作者 赵杰
出处 《江海学刊》 CSSCI 北大核心 2005年第4期118-124,共7页 Jianghai Academic Journal
  • 相关文献

参考文献8

二级参考文献38

  • 1张卫.测谎器面面观[J].国家安全通讯,2001(7):9-10. 被引量:1
  • 2宋英辉.关于测谎证据有关问题的探讨[J].法商研究,1999,17(5):14-16. 被引量:34
  • 3邢怀柱.刑事诉讼证据能力初论[J].现代法学,1996,18(1):44-46. 被引量:10
  • 4[美]乔恩·华尔兹.《刑事证据大全》.中国人民公安大学出版社1993年版,第315页.
  • 5See Frye v. United States,293 F. 1013(D. C. Cir. 1923).
  • 6See Paul C Giannelli,The Admissibility of novel scientific evidence:Frye v. United States,a half- century later, 80 Colum.L Rev(1980).
  • 7See Shauna Flenming Askim,United States v.Scheffer:An mxxnaly in the miltabyor a return to the per se ban of polygraph evidence,37 Hous. L Rev. 175(spring,2000).
  • 8See Edward J Imwinkelried,The Daubert decision on the admissibility of science evidence: The supreme cour-choose the right piece for all the evidentiary puzzles,9 St. John's J Legal Comment. 5,22(1993).
  • 9See John C Candam,Jr ,Military Rule of Evidence 707:A Bright line rule that needs to be dimmed, 140 MIL L REV.65,69(1993).
  • 10See United States v. Seheffer,523 U S 303(1998).

共引文献133

同被引文献100

引证文献15

二级引证文献29

相关作者

内容加载中请稍等...

相关机构

内容加载中请稍等...

相关主题

内容加载中请稍等...

浏览历史

内容加载中请稍等...
;
使用帮助 返回顶部