The current popular methods for decision making and project optimisation in mine ventilation contain a number of deficiencies as they are solely based on either subjective knowledge or objective information.This paper...The current popular methods for decision making and project optimisation in mine ventilation contain a number of deficiencies as they are solely based on either subjective knowledge or objective information.This paper presents a new approach to rank the alternatives by G1-coefficient of variation method.The focus of this approach is the use of the combination weighing,which is able to compensate for the deficiencies in the method of evaluation index single weighing.In the case study,an appropriate evaluation index system was established to determine the evaluation value of each ventilation mode.Then the proposed approach was used to select the best development face ventilation mode.The result shows that the proposed approach is able to rank the alternative development face ventilation mode reasonably,the combination weighing method had the advantages of both subjective and objective weighing methods in that it took into consideration of both the experience and wisdom of experts,and the new changes in objective conditions.This approach provides a more reasonable and reliable procedure to analyse and evaluate different ventilation modes.展开更多
针对逼近理想点排序法(technique for order preference by similarity to ideal solution,TOPSIS)存在的缺陷,提出基于Tanimoto系数和基于对称差的2种改进TOPSIS。改善或解决TOPSIS存在指标相关性问题、特殊样本集合无法比较优劣问题...针对逼近理想点排序法(technique for order preference by similarity to ideal solution,TOPSIS)存在的缺陷,提出基于Tanimoto系数和基于对称差的2种改进TOPSIS。改善或解决TOPSIS存在指标相关性问题、特殊样本集合无法比较优劣问题和样本数据动态变化时产生的逆序现象等缺陷;在稳定性、特异性、敏感性和有效性4方面对经典TOPSIS模型、改进Tanimoto模型和改进对称差模型进行对比验证,给出2种改进模型的适用场景。结果表明,2种方法各具有一定的优势。展开更多
基金Projects(51504286,51374242)supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of ChinaProject(2015M572270)supported by China Postdoctoral Science FoundationProject(2015RS4004)supported by the Science and Technology Plan of Hunan Province,China
文摘The current popular methods for decision making and project optimisation in mine ventilation contain a number of deficiencies as they are solely based on either subjective knowledge or objective information.This paper presents a new approach to rank the alternatives by G1-coefficient of variation method.The focus of this approach is the use of the combination weighing,which is able to compensate for the deficiencies in the method of evaluation index single weighing.In the case study,an appropriate evaluation index system was established to determine the evaluation value of each ventilation mode.Then the proposed approach was used to select the best development face ventilation mode.The result shows that the proposed approach is able to rank the alternative development face ventilation mode reasonably,the combination weighing method had the advantages of both subjective and objective weighing methods in that it took into consideration of both the experience and wisdom of experts,and the new changes in objective conditions.This approach provides a more reasonable and reliable procedure to analyse and evaluate different ventilation modes.
文摘针对逼近理想点排序法(technique for order preference by similarity to ideal solution,TOPSIS)存在的缺陷,提出基于Tanimoto系数和基于对称差的2种改进TOPSIS。改善或解决TOPSIS存在指标相关性问题、特殊样本集合无法比较优劣问题和样本数据动态变化时产生的逆序现象等缺陷;在稳定性、特异性、敏感性和有效性4方面对经典TOPSIS模型、改进Tanimoto模型和改进对称差模型进行对比验证,给出2种改进模型的适用场景。结果表明,2种方法各具有一定的优势。
